ScholarDesk

ScholarDesk/Comparisons/A portal or a spreadsheet

A portal or a spreadsheet

A spreadsheet is free, flexible and already open on your screen. It is the right tool for many funds. Here is where the line falls.

One click, no account. Open the coordinator desk or a student file; the data is fictional and nothing you change is kept.

Side by side

SpreadsheetPortal such as ScholarDesk
Who enters the dataThe coordinator, from e-mailsThe student, in a form
DocumentsIn folders and inboxesAttached to each request
Status for the studentOn request, by e-mailVisible at each step
TotalsFormulas to maintainCalculated on the register
HistoryDepends on who kept the fileKept with each student file
CostFree, plus the coordinator's timeA project or a monthly fee

Stay on the spreadsheet if

  • You pay fewer than about twenty awards a year
  • Each award is paid once
  • One person handles everything and will still be there next year

Think about a portal when

  • Awards run over several terms or years
  • Students send documents every term
  • Two or more people share the work
  • Your board or donors ask for figures you rebuild by hand each time

A middle path

If you stay on a spreadsheet, structure it as a system would: one row per request, fixed statuses, one list of payments. Our guide on leaving the spreadsheet describes that structure.

Questions

Asked before the first call

Can we bring our spreadsheet into ScholarDesk?

Yes. Students, universities and past payments are imported from Excel or CSV, with a check of every row.

Live demo

Judge it on what it does.

ScholarDesk is a working application, not a mock-up. Open the coordinator desk, approve a request, record a payment, then switch to a student file and send one yourself.